North and South Elizabeth Gaskell 9781479362141 Books
Download As PDF : North and South Elizabeth Gaskell 9781479362141 Books
Elizabeth Gaskell's North and South is set in Milton, North of England. As industrialization is changing the city Margaret Hale is forced to leave her tranquil rural south for the north where she witnesses the brutal world. During the clashes between the employers and the workers Hale sympathizes with the poor, idealizing their courage and tenacity. Mr. Thornton a cotton mill owner belonging to the upper class has much disdainful for his workers.
North and South Elizabeth Gaskell 9781479362141 Books
Don't get me wrong--Gaskell's novel is magnificent--a 5+++++. Where Dickens's portrait of England's early manufacturers and nascent factory system in Hard Times is caricature, Gaskell's is nuanced and complex. I wish this novel were better known and appreciated. My low rating is for the Penguin Classics edition, with introduction and notes by one Patricia Ingham, who is identified as a Fellow in English at St. Anne's College, Oxford. Since I was re-reading the novel, I disregarded the spoiler warning and read the introduction first. Apart from a few useful facts--e.g., that Gaskell originally intended to call her novel Margaret Hale after the protagonist but changed the title before publication in Dickens's Household Words, the introduction is mostly prefab class-and-gender analysis delivered in imprecise and inelegant jargon: "[Margaret] problematizes both the contemporary major discourses that justify [the workers'] emiseration: paternalism and 'the struggle for existence.' " The notes, by the way, which are not preceded by a spoiler warning, are full of spoilers; within the first couple of pages, at least two major plot developments are revealed. The notes are also full of Ms. Ingham's superfluous and condescending explanations of the significance of events and textual features (quotations, allusions, etc.) as if the benighted reader needs her guidance at every step. Finally, this edition is poorly produced: tiny font, poor contrast between page and type, and an inside margin so skimpy that it is difficult to read the full line without breaking the binding. What's happening at Penguin? at Oxford?Product details
|
Tags : North and South [Elizabeth Gaskell] on Amazon.com. *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. Elizabeth Gaskell's North and South is set in Milton, North of England. As industrialization is changing the city Margaret Hale is forced to leave her tranquil rural south for the north where she witnesses the brutal world. During the clashes between the employers and the workers Hale sympathizes with the poor,Elizabeth Gaskell,North and South,CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform,147936214X,Fiction Classics
People also read other books :
- Guitar Tabs Influx How to learn to read Guitar Tabs edition by Gene Petty Arts Photography eBooks
- The Aeneid By Virgil Illustrated Virgil 9781540715043 Books
- Night Templar A Vampire Queen Novel Vampire Queen Series Book 13 edition by Joey W Hill Literature Fiction eBooks
- Breezier Cheesier Newest and Bluest What Are Comparatives and Superlatives? (Audible Audio Edition) Brian P Cleary Intuitive Lerner Publishing Group Books
- Time Travels of the William Jefferson Clan eBook Ralph LeBlanc
North and South Elizabeth Gaskell 9781479362141 Books Reviews
I already knew the plot for North and South due to watching the movie. I read this book quickly because it was so good. I had to see what was in the next chapter. I found myself waking in the middle of the night to read it. It is written in old English but the makes it easy to read by defining words with a touch. It is romance but also so much deeper as you get to know each character and their persona struggles. I would read this book again - it is that good.
While I fully enjoy the actual novel North and South, this particular reproduction is not at all what I expected. It is titled and advertised that it is a hardcover version of Elizabeth Gaskell's North and South. It is NOT. The first few pages reference the constitutions of the free masons, then there are about 100+ blank pages, then pages 151-154 of the ending of North and South. Ridiculous - this should not be advertised as the North and South novel. There is a disclaimer page that "as a reproduction of a historical artifact, this work may contain missing or blurred pages, etc." but nowhere did it say that this didn't really have the novel at all. I feel this is mis-representation for something that costs over $20.
Loved the story. It ended more abruptly than I prefer, but it was a very satisfying ending nonetheless.
This version is a bit flimsy, but the editor’s notes are very, very helpful. However, they sometimes contain spoilers. If you’ve never read/watched the story, be cautious about the editor’s notes.
Also, unless you speak French, be prepared to Google something every couple chapters.
Written in the 1850s, North and South tells the story of Miss Margaret Hale, a young lady from southern, agrarian England and Mr. Thornton, a self-made, wealthy industrialist from northern England. Each is opposite to the other in all things so they begin their acquaintance at a disadvantage and continue being at odds throughout the whole course of the book. Miss Hale is proud, but likes helping her fellow man, because of her religion and because of her integrity. Mr. Thornton is proud of his accomplishments, but treats his workers with disdain. Each comes to understand and appreciate the other's viewpoint and grow as people.
The only thing I didn't care for in the book is the continuous diatribe about religion, which especially Margaret was always advocating. I had to compare it to Jane Austen's novels; although both authors had similar backgrounds from families with plenty of ministers, fathers, husbands, and brothers, being such, Austen's characters, while devout, don't talk about it incessantly.
This is a great read, and if you're familiar with or enjoy Austen's Pride and Prejudice, you will find similar plots, themes, and personalities. Gaskell's work is different in its own way to Austen's despite the similarities, and it raises important discussions on the image of Northern and Southern England, class, economics, and health that are fun to explore if you're a scholar. Many people coin this as the "darker" Pride and Prejudice, and in some ways it is. I mean, compared to Austen's own words that her work is sparkly, it's definitely different and some people are very concrete and stark on their opinions. Both are enjoyable and both are great to have on your shelf and both are important for their influence and study in Gregorian and Victorian England.
I have watched the series often because it is one of my favorites. As happens often the book is so much richer and sweeter, although I still consider the TV series one of my favorites. An excellent read that takes you into the center of another world, at another time!
The title refers to the north and south counties of England, the north industrial, the south rural. Young woman from south is forced to move with her family to a northern industrial town where she butts heads with a mill owner.
Themes include workers' rights; the tragic conditions of the poor and oppressed (most of whom are very honorable people); rampant disease (affecting all classes); unrequited love; familial devotion; spiritual faith; the price of success.
Hard to put down. Well developed characters in a character-driven story. Thoughtful, sometimes disturbing, and often romantic.
Historical setting early 1800's.
Don't get me wrong--Gaskell's novel is magnificent--a 5+++++. Where Dickens's portrait of England's early manufacturers and nascent factory system in Hard Times is caricature, Gaskell's is nuanced and complex. I wish this novel were better known and appreciated. My low rating is for the Penguin Classics edition, with introduction and notes by one Patricia Ingham, who is identified as a Fellow in English at St. Anne's College, Oxford. Since I was re-reading the novel, I disregarded the spoiler warning and read the introduction first. Apart from a few useful facts--e.g., that Gaskell originally intended to call her novel Margaret Hale after the protagonist but changed the title before publication in Dickens's Household Words, the introduction is mostly prefab class-and-gender analysis delivered in imprecise and inelegant jargon "[Margaret] problematizes both the contemporary major discourses that justify [the workers'] emiseration paternalism and 'the struggle for existence.' " The notes, by the way, which are not preceded by a spoiler warning, are full of spoilers; within the first couple of pages, at least two major plot developments are revealed. The notes are also full of Ms. Ingham's superfluous and condescending explanations of the significance of events and textual features (quotations, allusions, etc.) as if the benighted reader needs her guidance at every step. Finally, this edition is poorly produced tiny font, poor contrast between page and type, and an inside margin so skimpy that it is difficult to read the full line without breaking the binding. What's happening at Penguin? at Oxford?
0 Response to "⇒ Libro North and South Elizabeth Gaskell 9781479362141 Books"
Post a Comment